Brooks tends to fit slightly short, so most runners need a half size up from street shoes, while New Balance running shoes fit true to size in length. For width choice, New Balance offers a wider range of narrow to extra-wide fittings, while Brooks offers four widths in selected styles. Shoe width is the letter-coded fit across the forefoot, from narrow through standard to wide. Starting from your normal street size and standard width helps you compare both brands without guessing.
Medical information disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes only and does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a physician or other qualified health professional about symptoms, medications, tests, or treatment decisions.
Table of Contents
- Do you need a half size up?
- What do standard, wide, and narrow mean?
- Which brand fits wide or narrow feet better?
- How should you check fit before running?
Do you need a half size up?
Brooks Running Customer Care states its shoes fit slightly shorter than other brands and recommends ordering one-half size to one size larger than casual or dress shoes Brooks sizing guidance. That advice matters most for runners buying between sizes or with longer toes.
Marathon Handbook describes the same split in direct comparison: Brooks requires a half-size up from street shoes while New Balance running shoes fit true to size in length Marathon Handbook comparison. If you wear both brands, expect your Brooks size to read slightly larger.
What do standard, wide, and narrow mean?
Both brands use D as the men's standard width and B as the women's standard width, reports Boost Health Collective. Runners switching brands can therefore start from the same baseline letter.
Brooks makes Narrow, Medium, Wide, and Extra Wide options, but notes that not every style or color is produced in every width Brooks width options. New Balance NZ Help Center lists men's widths from 2A Extra Narrow through D Standard to 6E XX-Wide, and women's from 4A through B Standard to 4E New Balance width guide.
Which brand fits wide or narrow feet better?
Marathon Handbook finds a better fit is more likely with New Balance than Brooks for shoppers with wide feet or abnormally narrow feet because of broader width availability. The extra steps at each end, such as 2A and 6E for men, give more room to move up or down.
That advantage has a limit. Boost Health Collective notes the widest New Balance fittings, up to 6E for men and 4E for women, appear only in selected models. Those models may not include lightweight performance racers.
How should you check fit before running?
Shop in the late afternoon when feet are largest, advises New Balance NZ Help Center. Feet swell during the day, so morning-only try-ons can hide pressure. Use this quick check:.
- Heel should feel snug with no slipping.
- Toe box should leave enough room to wiggle toes.
- Walk and jog in the store before deciding.