Most beginner runners should buy the Brooks Ghost 17 or Asics Gel-Cumulus 27 first. A daily trainer means a comfortable road shoe for everyday easy miles, and those two offer the best mix of versatility and value. The Brooks Glycerin 22 suits runners who want maximum plushness for longer, slower miles and will pay more. All three are neutral shoes for runners without major inward roll.
Medical information disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes only and does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a physician or other qualified health professional about symptoms, medications, tests, or treatment decisions.
Table of Contents
- What are the three shoes?
- How do they feel on the road?
- Which should you buy first?
- When should you skip these shoes?
What are the three shoes?
The Brooks Ghost 17 is a neutral daily trainer with mid-to-high cushioning. Fleet Feet reports it measures 37mm heel and 27mm forefoot for a 10mm drop, weighs about 286g men's and 255g women's, and retails for $150 in its Ghost 17 review. The Brooks Glycerin 22 is a neutral max-cushion daily trainer at 38mm heel and 28mm forefoot for a 10mm drop.
It weighs about 289g men's and 257g women's at $165 retail. The Asics Gel-Cumulus 27 is a neutral medium-cushion daily trainer with 38.5mm heel and 30.5mm forefoot for an 8mm drop. Find My Footwear lists it at about 270g in men's 9.5 with a $140 launch price in its Cumulus 27 review.
How do they feel on the road?
Ghost 17 uses nitrogen-infused DNA Loft v3 foam. It adds 1mm in the heel and 3mm in the forefoot versus Ghost 16, while drop falls from 12mm to 10mm for smoother everyday miles. Glycerin 22 uses nitrogen-infused dual-cell DNA Tuned foam.
Larger heel cells soften landing, smaller forefoot cells aid toe-off, and a broad platform steadies transitions. Gel-Cumulus 27 pairs FF Blast Plus foam with PureGEL in the heel to soften rearfoot impact. That setup gives a firmer, more traditional and versatile ride than max-stack Nimbus 27.
Which should you buy first?
Start with Ghost 17 or Cumulus 27 if you want value and versatility for short runs, walk-run days, and first training blocks. Choose Glycerin 22 if longer, slower miles beat you up and you want extra plushness.
Price gaps matter for beginners replacing shoes often. Comfort preference also matters, because medium cushion feels quicker and max cushion feels softer.
- Pick Ghost 17 for balanced cushion and $150 everyday use.
- Pick Gel-Cumulus 27 for a lighter-feeling, lower-drop option at $140.
- Pick Glycerin 22 for maximum softness at $165 for slow distance.
When should you skip these shoes?
Skip all three if your ankles roll sharply inward. That pattern is called overpronation, and neutral cushion will not control it.
Beginners who overpronate need stability instead, such as Brooks Adrenaline GTS with GuideRails or Asics Gel-Kayano and GT-2000 with 4D Guidance System, according to RunToTheFinish in its Ghost versus Glycerin guide. Visit a run shop for a gait check and try on both brands before buying, because stack, weight, fit, and comfort change with size, foot shape, and gait.
2 thoughts on “Asics vs Brooks for Beginner Runners: Which Daily Trainer to Buy First”
Comments are closed.